North York Second Storey Addition: 8-Month Documentation

We’re finally done. After 8 months of planning, permits, and construction, our North York bungalow (c. 1958, Willowdale area) now has a full second storey. Here’s what the experience looked like.

Before:

  • 1,050 sq ft bungalow, 3 beds/1 bath on main floor
  • Full basement (unfinished, used for storage and laundry)
  • 45-foot lot, mature maple in front yard

What we added:

  • Full second storey: 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms (including ensuite), laundry upstairs
  • Main floor: opened kitchen to dining, new powder room added
  • Basement: left for phase 2

The numbers:

  • Design/engineering: $22,000
  • Permit (City of Toronto): $4,200
  • Construction: $318,000
  • Contingency used: $14,000 (window supply delay, unexpected load-bearing beam)
  • Total: $358,000

Timeline:

  • Week 1–6: Permit application and waiting
  • Week 7: Permit in hand
  • Week 8–12: Demo, temporary roof, structural steel
  • Week 13–26: Framing, rough mechanical, insulation, drywall
  • Week 27–34: Finishes — cabinets, tile, paint, trim

Lived elsewhere for 6 months. This is the part people underestimate — not just financially but logistically and emotionally.

Was it worth it?

Yes. We’re now in a 2,200 sq ft home on a street where comparable properties sell for $1.6–1.9M. Our all-in cost was ~$1.1M (original purchase + reno). The math works if you’re staying.

Ask your second storey questions at home.renovation.reviews.