# ICF basement walls on our new build in Caledon: builder comparison and 3-year performance review

**URL:** <https://home.renovation.reviews/t/icf-basement-walls-on-our-new-build-in-caledon-builder-comparison-and-3-year-performance-review/46837>\
**Category:** Ontario\
**Created:** [April 26, 2026, 5:56pm UTC](https://home.renovation.reviews/t/icf-basement-walls-on-our-new-build-in-caledon-builder-comparison-and-3-year-performance-review/46837 "2026-04-26T17:56:00Z")\
**Posts on this page:** 1\
**Page:** 1

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![system](https://home.renovation.reviews/user_avatar/home.renovation.reviews/system/32/77_2.png) [@system](https://home.renovation.reviews/u/system)\
**Post date:** [April 26, 2026, 5:56pm UTC](https://home.renovation.reviews/t/icf-basement-walls-on-our-new-build-in-caledon-builder-comparison-and-3-year-performance-review/46837/1 "2026-04-26T17:56:00Z")

</div>

We built a custom home in Caledon in 2022 and specified ICF (Insulated Concrete Form) for the full basement walls. Three years in, here is what we know.

**Why we chose ICF:** Our previous house had a conventional poured concrete basement. Despite full interior framing, insulation, and vapour barrier, the basement always felt slightly damp and cool. The interior framing also ate 4 inches of space on every wall perimeter. We wanted a different approach.

**Builder resistance:** Our first two builders quoted ICF but both said “we prefer poured concrete, ICF is more complicated.” The third builder specialized in ICF (Arxx system) and explained why: the forming requires different skilled labour (not complicated, just different — and their crew was experienced). We went with them.

**The ICF system spec:** Logix Platinum, 8-inch core (R-32 total wall assembly when you include both foam faces). The walls run from the footing to the top of the foundation — approximately 9 feet of wall height.

**Finishing the basement:** No interior wall framing required. We applied 2x2 furring strips at 16-inch centres directly to the foam face, then 5/8-inch drywall. Total wall thickness added to interior: 3.5 inches. The furring also allowed us to run electrical horizontally without touching the concrete.

**3-year performance numbers:**

- January basement temperature (unheated, no mechanical, just passive from house above): 14°C. Our neighbour with similar poured concrete construction: 8°C.
- No condensation on any basement wall surface in 3 winters.
- RH in basement: 42-48% year-round without a dehumidifier.

**Our previous house with conventional basement:** Required a 70-pint dehumidifier running May–September, RH often reached 65%+ without it.

**Construction cost premium vs conventional poured:** Our builder estimated $18,000 additional for the full basement ICF vs conventional. We paid zero in separate basement insulation, saved approximately $9,000 in framing and insulation labour, and eliminated the dehumidifier requirement ($300/year for 30 years = $9,000 present value). Net premium: approximately $0 over 30 years.

Three-year verdict: ICF for any finished Ontario basement is the obvious choice. We would specify it again without hesitation.
