# Full roof replacement on our 2001 Whitchurch-Stouffville home: metal over old shingles, 18-month review

**URL:** <https://home.renovation.reviews/t/full-roof-replacement-on-our-2001-whitchurch-stouffville-home-metal-over-old-shingles-18-month-review/46819>\
**Category:** Ontario\
**Created:** [April 26, 2026, 5:33pm UTC](https://home.renovation.reviews/t/full-roof-replacement-on-our-2001-whitchurch-stouffville-home-metal-over-old-shingles-18-month-review/46819 "2026-04-26T17:33:54Z")\
**Posts on this page:** 1\
**Page:** 1

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![system](https://home.renovation.reviews/user_avatar/home.renovation.reviews/system/32/77_2.png) [@system](https://home.renovation.reviews/u/system)\
**Post date:** [April 26, 2026, 5:33pm UTC](https://home.renovation.reviews/t/full-roof-replacement-on-our-2001-whitchurch-stouffville-home-metal-over-old-shingles-18-month-review/46819/1 "2026-04-26T17:33:54Z")

</div>

We replaced the 20-year-old architectural shingles on our Whitchurch-Stouffville rural property with standing seam steel 18 months ago. Here is the honest assessment.

**Why we chose metal:** We get significant snow load and had two ice dam incidents in the previous roof’s last years — one caused interior damage to a dormer wall. We have a metal equipment building on the property (no ice dams, no leaks in 15 years). The lifetime cost calculation made sense.

**The assessment:** Our roofer (metal specialty contractor, York Region) assessed whether we could go over the existing shingles (one layer only, which we had) or needed a full tear-off. His assessment: the existing shingle layer was irregular enough in places that metal over shingles would create read-through on the exposed metal surface. We did a full tear-off.

**What was discovered on tear-off:** Two sections of OSB roof sheathing near the ice dam areas had soft spots. Total area: approximately 80 sqft. Replaced before steel installation: $600 extra.

**Metal system installed:** 1-inch factory-formed standing seam panels, 26-gauge steel (G-90 galvanized), concealed fastener system. Ridge cap and hip cap in matching steel. Painted system (Kynar coating), colour matched to existing grey shutters.

**Cost:** $18,400 for 2,200 sqft roof with one complex valley and three dormers.

**18-month review:** Zero ice dams last winter (significant snow year). The metal is loud in heavy rain — we expected this and it doesn’t bother us (sounds like a drumroll). The snow sheds off the south face in sheets — we installed snow guards above the front door and mudroom entry ($380 extra) which was the right call. Zero leaks, zero maintenance.
